A Star Is Born
If Bradley Cooper
Could direct himself in more
Movies, that’d be great.
I’m the perfect audience for “A Star Is Born:” I had a Lady Gaga song on my Bar Mitzvah CD (Poker Face, obviously), I believe Bradley Cooper can do no wrong (All About Steve as the exception) and I’m uncorrupted by the shittiness of the previous remakes of the movie. I didn’t even know this was the fourth go at the story until right before its release, and that was after I had already seen the preview just under one million times in theaters this summer. And while I didn’t fall head over heels for this version the way Lady Gaga’s Ally does for Bradley Cooper’s Jackson Maine and vice versa, I did really like it. Really!
For starters, “A Star Is Born” is pure movie magic. The first half of the film is so thrilling to watch unfold that it practically radiates energy from the screen, and that’s because Gaga and Cooper are electrifying when they take the stage together. And that moment when he brings her on stage to sing Shallow for the first time? Damn. When she hits those notes at the end of the song, I felt every hair on my arms stand on end. This wasn’t the sequel to a Jack Black movie based on a series of beloved kids books by R.L. Stine, but I saw some serious goosebumps in the theater today. It’s just such an emotional and powerful and exciting moment, it’s practically worth the price of admission itself. Scratch that, it is worth the price of admission itself.
And that’s a good thing, because the movie starts to fall apart in the second half. I can’t pinpoint exactly when, but at some point after Ally goes orange and before Jackson Maine checks into rehab, the movie starts to lose its steam. The movie feels about 20 minutes too long by the time it reaches its teary conclusion, and yet the emotional points of the plot in the second half still feel glossed over. So while I’m not suggesting that what I need is a 4-hour director’s cut that dives deeper into Ally and Jackson’s life post-marriage, I’m not, not saying that, either.
Although the story is far too predictable and the second half is less good than the amazing first half, I’ll definitely be recommending “A Star Is Born” to peeps who ask me what I thought about it. I definitely think it should be nominated for all the awards it has coming its way, though it shouldn’t necessarily win. I have a feeling that I’ll be raving about many more movies come February.