First Reformed
This is the movie
The expression “tour de force”
Was invented for.
Have you ever returned to one of your all-time favorite movies and wondered what it would feel like to watch it again for the first time? “First Reformed” is the rare movie that gives you that feeling the first time you watch it. From its opening scene, I knew I was in the presence of greatness.
I had plenty of opportunities to see “First Reformed” in theaters this summer, but I never got around to it. I wish I had, because summers have a track record of producing some of my favorite movies of the year (“The Lobster,” “Sing Street,” “Hunt for the Wilderpeople”), and I could’ve spent the last six months campaigning for my friends to see it instead of trying to convert non-horror fans into “Hereditary” apologists. I can only imagine how I would have felt seeing “First Reformed” in theaters, which sports even more of a Sopranos ending than The Sopranos. Instead, I watched it on my iPad (cue the “Roma” debates) coming back from Christmas in St. Louis, and I was not okay for the rest of the drive home. I needed to go for a walk to clear my head, but I was trapped in the confines of my sister’s ’08 Corolla. My advice: Watch “First Reformed” with a loved one so you have someone to talk about it with after, and watch it near a gym so you can hop on the treadmill for a few miles while you contemplate what you just witnessed.
“First Reformed” gave me the same giddy feeling that I got while watching “Phantom Thread.” Those of you who have seen either of these movies are probably questioning how the fuck either of them made me feel giddy, but I honestly felt pure excitement while watching them. In both movies, nearly every shot crackles with silent uncertainty, and just when you think you know what the movies are about, bang, you realize you were sorely mistaken. Ethan Hawke has “risen” to be one of my favorite actors (risen, get it) after “Boyhood” and catching up on The Before Trilogy, and he really solidifies himself as such here. I can’t recommend “First Reformed” enough, and I’m excited to watch it again – I guess instant re-watching is the good part about waiting to see it until it hit Amazon Prime. Hawke and the movie’s screenplay might be its only chance at Oscar nominations, but if it were up to me, it’d be a frontrunner in every category.