Ad Astra
I don’t think I’d mind
If we took a pause on space
Pics for a while.
Every so often, a movie critic comes along who reignites my love for my love for movies and writing about them. When I was a kid, it was Roger Ebert. Most recently, it’s David Erhlich – and I was lucky enough to get coffee with him last week. When we met, we talked about the triumphs and the perils of making a living as a writer, and specifically as a film critic. I told him that I find it much harder to write about a movie I loved than a movie I hated. David, on the other hand, said there’s nothing harder for him than writing about a movie that leaves him feeling absolutely indifferent. I admitted that I’m sometimes guilty of skipping reviews when I feel ambivalent about a movie, and he challenged me to embrace the review of the next movie I feel indifferent about. Little did I know, that movie would rear its apathetic head the very next day, in the form of Ad motherfucking Astra.
In the second half of this decade, we’ve seen Matthew and Ryan go to space, the true story of the women who got us to space and Sandra and George get lost in space. And now, in 2019, we’ve decided to send Brad to the stars as well. The excellent “Hidden Figures” aside, what all these movies share, aside from space, is a failure to elicit a response from me much stronger than a “Yeah that was pretty good.” I don’t know what it is about space movies, but they just don’t do much for me. I love science fiction, so no it’s not that. I just don’t relate to them, and as a result they don’t resonate with me. It’s funny, because my best friend just started his PhD program in astrophysics. He like really loved “Interstellar.” I thought it was pretty good.
For me, “Ad Astra” shined when it was at its most intense, and I was pleasantly surprised with how many pockets of intensity there were throughout its 124-minute runtime. Some scenes were so intense, some images so hard to take in, I was instantly reminded of this summer’s “Midsommar” and Ari Aster’s devilishly unshakable moments of gut-churnery (yes I just made gut-churnery up – if you will it, it is no dream). Most space movies feel claustrophobic, but Ad Astra didn’t. Instead of chest-tightening tight shots, each shot is filled with enough emotion to pack a punch Brad Pitt right in his pretty boy mouth. And Pitt, by the way, is definitely (inter)stellar as an astronaut on a mission to find the father who may not be the hero he’s romanticized – but I’d much rather see him get the Oscar nod for “Once Upon a Time.”
Spoiler culture would probably deem this a spoiler, so spoiler haters beware: I ultimately found Ad Astra’s ending rather anticlimactic. After some of the most intense sequences of the year, the ending just felt like a letdown of the “Really, that’s it?” variety. It’s not predictable per se, but it’s not quite unpredictable, either. It just left me feeling kind of empty, but not in the good, gutting way that a movie can. My recommendation? If you love space shit, you’ll love this. Otherwise, you can wait til it hits HBO in six months.