Captain Marvel
You can go see it
Or you can stay on the couch.
Both are good options.
Can movies be properly reviewed after just one viewing? How much time must transpire between the viewing and the reviewing for the review to be “fair”? These are the questions I ask myself after waiting two weeks to write my “Captain Marvel” review; questions I could have answered if the one film criticism class the J-school offers had more than just one 8 am lecture.
Two weeks later, and I’m feeling very indifferent about Captain Marvel. And my notes look like they were written in Kree! (This joke would be a lot funnier if I didn’t have to Google the plot of the movie to remember what those aliens were called.) For real, though, the latest installment in the MCU is pretty unremarkable. It’s passable fodder while we wait for Endgame to blow our minds next month, but if you aren’t so obsessive-compulsive that you need to see every Marvel movie within the first two weeks they’re in theaters, then you can skip this one.
My biggest qualm with Captain Marvel (the movie, not the character) is that, for an origin story, it’s not very epic. What made the first Iron Man and Captain America movies so great was how we got to join the characters on their journeys to becoming superheroes (which I just misspelled as superhoes) and all that entails: getting their powers, accepting the responsibilities of those powers, battling internally in order to save the world from external threats. In Captain Marvel, you hardly get a taste of who Carol Danvers was before her memory was wiped, and while she struggles to figure out who she really is, so does the movie. I’m not suggesting that every Marvel movie should hit the same notes and follow the same archetypal journeys – believe me, I’m all for superhero movies subverting conventions. It’s just that, when Danvers finally unleashes her true powers and saves the day, it doesn’t feel like we as an audience earned this moment, because we didn’t get to experience all the obstacles Danvers overcame to get to this moment. Carol Danvers deserves better than Captain Marvel. The MCU’s most powerful superhero deserves a more epic introduction.
Part of why I didn’t love Captain Marvel is because I typically prefer when the MCU stays grounded on Earth. Maybe that’s small-minded of me, but with the exception of “Guardians” (which I still didn’t love as much as everyone else), the characters just seem more well-rounded when their superheroes aren’t jumping from planets to find that what they’ve been looking for was inside them the whole time. Plus, the stakes just feel higher.
I’ve also realized that I like Marvel movies better when I go in with no expectations. I had absolutely none going into “Doctor Strange” and straight up loved it, but I think too much excitement for “Black Panther” ultimately hurt how much I enjoyed it when my expectations weren’t met. My expectations were fairly high for Captain Marvel since she’s the strongest mother-fucking superhero in the universe, so I think that also helps explain why I’m not still raving about this one. But even though I’ve talked some shit today, Captain Marvel was far from my least favorite movies in the MCU (shout out to Thor.) If you can get past the plot holes and unanswered questions it leaves you with, it makes for an entertaining afternoon at the movies. I just want to know, why did it take 21 installments to introduce Annette Bening to the MCU? Figure it out, casting directors.